[Nameplate] T-storm ~ 62°F  
High: 80°F ~ Low: 56°F
Saturday, Apr. 30, 2016

Bears shot at Union home

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Photo courtesy of Arkansas Game and Fish Commission
Adrenaline got the best of a man in Union on Oct. 10, when he was called to his mother's home to protect her and her sister from a mother bear and her three cubs.

The sow and three cubs were shot by Bruce Knapp, 48, of Pineville. The sow and one of the cubs was shot out of a tree on the property, then Knapp walked across the road where the other two cubs were and shot them, said Brian Gaskins, wildlife officer for the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission.

Gaskins responded to Knapp's call on Oct. 10 to the AGFC, after he had shot the four bears. He retrieved the bears and spoke with Knapp and his mother, the property owner, and his aunt, the driver of the vehicle who discovered the bears on the property.

"(Knapp's mother) was a bit scared because of the bears," Gaskins said. She had been in the home at the time the bears were discovered. "We've had reports of bears out there for many years, but this was her first time seeing them so she was kind of shook up."

The aunt pulled up in her vehicle and saw the bears. Her presence startled the sow that then jumped into the dog pen, next to the house where Knapp's mother remained. The dog pen was covered by a solid wooden fence facing the street, Gaskin said.

The aunt began honking her horn, and the sow jumped out of the dog pen over the fence. One of the three cubs went up a tree about 20 yards from the front porch of the residence. The sow went with her cub. The other two cubs were across the road, where they remained while the aunt and mother called Knapp, Gaskin said.

Knapp then came over to discover the sow and her cub making noise in the tree. He shot the sow and cub then proceeded across the road and shot the other two cubs, who had become startled and were making noises, Gaskins said.

"The bears were up a tree growling or making noises, they were scared with the noise excitement," he said. Gaskin estimated that the cubs were born in the spring 2009.

"As far I could tell this bear has not been caught and tagged," Gaskins said, from which he was able to infer that the sow was not a nuisance bear.

"The bears had not done any damage at this point," Gaskins said. "They were just there. Chances are they were just looking for food or smelled something, whether it be table scraps dog food, whatever it may be. The other two that ran off were of no danger to anyone. The cubs were small cubs. It was just through adrenaline, excitement with four bears."

The initial reaction of seeing a bear in the woods can lead to a defensive reaction, but the best reaction is to leave the bear alone.

"If you see them, just avoid them," Gaskins said.

"If a person has a problem with a bear, and it's doing damage, not just being seen, they live in the woods, don't take it upon yourself to shoot them. Call us and we will get the right personnel out there to take care of it. Just seeing a bear is not a bad thing," Gaskins said.

"In this situation, I feel that if they would have just went in the house the sow and the cub would have come down the tree and left the residence," Gaskins said. If the AGFC had been called instead of the bears being shot, a state biologist would have set a trap and tried to relocate the animals.

"Just because a bear is there, you don't shoot it," Gaskins said. "In this situation the cub went up a tree so the sow followed it. If the cub would have followed the other two then they all would have left out of the yard."

Gaskins ticketed Knapp on Oct. 16 with failure to comply with depredation permit requirement, after consulting with AGFC personnel.

Depredation Permit Requirement, AGFC Code 18.09, reads "It shall be unlawful for any person, including a property owner or designee, to take or attempt to take any game or furbearing animal committing damage to crops or personal property without obtaining a Depredation Permit and complying with the terms of said permit."

Knapp was ticketed and will go before district court on Nov. 11. He will be liable for a fine of $100 to $1,000, according to the AGFC Code.

Although the bears had not done any damage to the property, the AGFC took the requirement as penalty under the circumstance of the situation, Gaskins said.

If a nuisance bear is discovered on private property, the AGFC should be called. Damage caused by a bear can then be examined and a degradation permit can be retested, and if need be, an AGFC biologist can trap the bear(s) and relocate them, Gaskins said.

Television programs can send a bad message about bears, when the only bear experience is a growling set of teeth.

"These are black bears not brown or Grissly," Gaskins said. "They eat fruit, berries, insects and small mammals."

Gaskins has served in the AGFC since 1985. He has observed the black bear in its native Arkansas habitat, and has never had to handle an incident where a black bear was showing aggression toward a human, he said.

"Most of it was getting in the barn eating sweet feed, breaking in to a hunting cabin after smelling bacon or scraps, pushing screens in and doors in and just looking for food," he said. "It smells food and is wanting to eat."

This is the second reported, unauthorized killing of bears this season. A dead bear was dumped in Seymour, Mo., in mid-September.

Bear hunting season has been conducted in Arkansas annually since 1980. The seasons are listed as follows: archery, Oct. 1 to Nov. 30; muzzling loading, Oct. 17 to 25; modern gun, Nov. 9 to Nov. 30. Anyone that has a valid hunting license has a bag limit of one bear.

"What we are trying to achieve is a maximum numbers of bears that can sustain a healthy bear population," said Myron Means, statewide black bear program coordinator for AGFC. Bears are unique, and even though the landscape can support the population the human tolerance to bear population may be well under what the habitat can support, Means said.

"Bears are the only thing that you have this type of issue with. We really have to govern our bear population on the sociological carrying capacity not to the habitat population," he said.

The AGFC monitors bear populations throughout Arkansas and the complaints that come with them. A lot of a management of the bear population is based on nuisance activities, Means said.

"It is kind of strange that people are new to bear issues. Any time that you have areas on the fringes of bear populations as they expand, you are going to have a lot of people that have never had bear around. When bear start showing up in these areas, naturally, those people are going to be more fearful and less tolerant than people smack dab in the middle of bear country."

That "bear country" is defined as the Ozark/St. Francis National Forest, which runs from the Oklahoma line into White County. Fringe areas to the north, such as Izard, Sharp and Fulton counties, are expected to have a bear population.

Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. If you feel that a comment is offensive, please Login or Create an account first, and then you will be able to flag a comment as objectionable. Please also note that those who post comments on areawidenews.com may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.


-- Posted by underestimated99 on Thu, Oct 22, 2009, at 5:59 PM

where i grew up in north idaho i picked any number of gallons of huckleberries along side of black bears that were doing the same thing, and we got along just fine. i left them alone and they left me alone. now i read that a fulton county resident has actually killed 4 black bears.

it is inconceivable to me. he just rared back and shot 4 black bears. he needs to spend time in the pen.

-- Posted by revenueagent on Thu, Oct 22, 2009, at 7:43 PM

The stupidity resides in sheeple who buy into the gunverment line that everything is the government's--private property, wildlife, hunting rights, even our own personal lives, and THEY (gov't) doles out what we can and cannot do with ourselves.

Property owners have to wait until after a bear destroys their possessions, and call some stooge to come inspect the damage to determine whether they will permit the owner to protect what is his? When I read that it was a sow separated from her cubs, I immediately thought, "that is an extreme danger."

Don't buy what the AGFC is telling us--if black bears are harmless, lovable, primary herbivores, then why did one kill a 6 year old girl while seriously injure her mother and brother who were trying to rescue her?!! http://www.southeasternoutdoors.com/wild...

WAKE UP!! Protect your rights! The government will not!!

-- Posted by jomomma on Fri, Oct 23, 2009, at 11:27 AM

It's sad that the bear and cubs had to be shot so somebody could play hero. The residents were not in any danger. One phone call to the Arkansas Fish and Wildlife and the animals could have been relocated.

-- Posted by goatgirl on Fri, Oct 23, 2009, at 10:27 PM

Just read Salem's "The News", my Sunday was ruined with the read on the bear and her three cubs. My guts continued to roll.

Accordingly, I'll enter my two cents worth on this unfortunate story and don't care if any reader's feathers get ruffled.

If Mr. Knapp's family, himself or property (livestock, etc) were truly being threatened by bear, I'd say shoot and worry about any AGFC regulations at a later time.

However, neither Knapp, family or property were threatened, pursued or attacked, and the bear(s) were undoubtedly near that residence looking for food, as Officer Gaskins stated.

Perhaps I'm not allowing Mr. Knapp much leeway here, but will bet he also sees the need to crush turtles crossing the road, hunts deer for the rack they happen to be carrying or shoots the bobcat that happens into his rifle sights.

Fear by Mr. Knapp-doubtful. Fear by the bears-yes, proven by that car horn precipitating the hasty tree climb by cub and sow.

If those bears had been left alone they'd have retreated to the woods.

Hopefully in November the District Court gives Mr. Macho Man the maximum $ 1,000.00 fine. Too bad that amount isn't tenfold.

Yeah, Mr. Knapp fella, you're a real hero.

-- Posted by Hillbilly Too on Sun, Oct 25, 2009, at 7:23 PM

This is truly unfortunate. Ignorance is no excuse for this slaughter. I'm with Hillbilly Too in wishing that the fine could be tenfold. Maybe I'm just on a roll because of something we discovered last week. We had stopped our vehicle near a stream to allow our dog out. He ran down by the water and began barking wildly. Upon investigation, we found the carcasses of 2 does. The backstraps had been removed from both of them, then their remains had been dumped into the creek. I sincerely wish that people would stop killing what they won't eat. Taking a choice portion of an animal and dumping the rest is criminal and morally wrong. I hope whoever did this gets theirs.

-- Posted by ldenny58 on Mon, Oct 26, 2009, at 2:04 PM


Why only a $100 - $1000 fine?

Shooting a bear with a gun during bow season is illegal!

Shooting a sow with a cub is illegal!

Shooting a cub (x 3) is illegal!

Shooting near a road is illegal!

Shooting near a residence is illegal!

Lots of fines here, jail time would be appropriate!

-- Posted by arkienow on Mon, Oct 26, 2009, at 7:12 PM

my day was also ruined when i read the ignorance of this man shooting these bear. all i could do was shake my head with disgust and am still wondering why he received such a small fine? i am also wondering what had to be "taken into consideration" when determining the punishment? fear out of ignorance and stupidity does NOT, in any way lessen the severity of the incident. shame on you-i hope everyone recognizes your name and remembers what kind of "hero wannabe" you truly are. and shame on you AGFC for letting this slide...

-- Posted by akoyaqueen on Wed, Oct 28, 2009, at 7:18 PM

I grew up in Arkansas and we always had a lot of wild animals around us but we would never shoot them, especially if they were being harmless..No doubt the Mother Cub was making noises at her Cub for not coming along with the rest. I agree that the AGFC should have been allowed to trap and relocate the bears..I think the fine should be much harsher than what is stipulated! What a sad story.

-- Posted by bonnie13 on Fri, Nov 13, 2009, at 11:51 PM

Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: